Giants’ JJ McCarthy officially listed as QB2 on New York’s Week 5 depth chart

The New York Giants have swiftly rearranged their quarterback depth chart, officially listing JJ McCarthy as the secondary starter (QB2) behind Jameis Winston for their Week 5 matchup against the Washington Commanders. This change marks a pivotal moment in McCarthy's NFL comeback following adversity. Selected tenth overall by Minnesota in 2024, the Michigan native missed his entire rookie campaign due to a torn meniscus that necessitated surgery.

He subsequently made 10 starts in 2025, recording 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. Following his trade to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round draft pick, McCarthy now competes with veteran Jameis Winston, who remains the unquestionable starter following his stellar Week 4 performance, throwing for 36 points. Head coach John Harbaugh hinted at McCarthy potentially overtaking Haener for the primary backup role during Monday's press conference, stating, "I think that's a possibility.

We'll see how it goes during the week, but that's definitely on the table." With Haener on the practice squad, McCarthy has firmly secured the QB2 designation after impressing coaches with his understanding of the offense and progress during practice. McCarthy's rapid promotion suggests the Giants are growing increasingly confident in his development.