CJI Surya Kant says SC will soon decide on plea to recall CEC law order
CJI Surya Kant said the Supreme Court will soon decide on a plea seeking recall of its order referring the challenge to the CEC appointment law to a Constitution bench.
Chief Justice Surya Kant announced on Wednesday his intention to review an application requesting the reversal of the Supreme Court's divided judgment in the case questioning the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. Senior Attorney Gopal Sankaranarayanan presented the interlocutory application to the Chief Justice, explaining that it seeks the reconsideration of the September 23 ruling issued by a panel consisting of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma.
CJI Clarifies Next Steps "We will examine and then take a call," Chief Justice Surya Kant stated after hearing Sankaranarayanan's request. The counsel also notified the court about a separate curative petition filed by another party challenging the split verdict. The Chief Justice mentioned he had read about the curative petition, leading Sankaranarayanan to confirm it had been filed by a different party.
He clarified that the curative petition must follow a review process. Rooted in Bias Concern The petition was lodged by Naman Shrestra, who expressed doubts about Justice Sharma's impartiality due to his son's involvement as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India (ECI). The applicant alleged that Justice Sharma had not disclosed his son's connection to the ECI during the proceedings.
This focus on judicial transparency and potential conflict of interest sets the stage for the Chief Justice's examination of the application. Split Verdict Leads to Larger Bench Reference On September 23, Justice Datta and Justice Sharma held divergent opinions regarding the referral of the petitions challenging the CEC law to a larger bench.
Justice Datta argued that such a referral was unnecessary, while Justice Sharma disagreed. Consequently, the bench decided to refer the matter to a five-judge bench and assigned it to the Chief Justice of India. Following the verdict, LiveLaw reported that Justice Sharma's son is the ECI's designated counsel in the Madhya Pradesh High Court.
Recall Plea Adds Complexity The latest application introduces an additional legal issue to a case already characterized by a divided judicial opinion and a referral to a larger bench. Now, the Chief Justice must determine whether the circumstances outlined in the application warrant further deliberation on the September 23 judgment.
As of now, the Chief Justice has not made a decision on the plea, stating that he will review it before rendering a judgment.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- CJI Surya Kant To Examine Plea Seeking Recall Of Split Verdict In CEC Law Case freepressjournal.in
- CEC appointment law row: SC to examine plea seeking recall of September split verdict livemint.com
- "Will Take Call": Supreme Court On Plea To Recall Verdict On Poll Panel Appointment Law ndtv.com
- CJI agrees to take a call on hearing a plea to recall split verdict in CEC appointments law case thehindu.com
- Supreme Court’s latest move on split verdict over law to appoint CEC indianexpress.com