Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

World

Ajman court clears woman after doubts over WhatsApp messages

Ajman: The Ajman Appeal Court has overturned the conviction of an Egyptian woman accused of embezzlement and breach of trust, ruling that doubts over the authenticity of WhatsApp evidence and a lack of proof that money was ever handed over warranted her acquittal. According to court records, the retired dentist was accused of taking possession of money entrusted to her under an agency arrangement…

Ajman court clears woman after doubts over WhatsApp messages

The Ajman Appeal Court has overturned the conviction of an Egyptian woman accused of embezzlement and breach of trust, dismissing concerns about the authenticity of WhatsApp evidence and the lack of proof that money was indeed transferred. The retired dentist was initially charged with unlawfully keeping money entrusted to her under an agency arrangement, resulting in a Dh5,000 fine and court costs from the Ajman Court of First Instance in July.

However, the appeal court, comprising three judges, found that the prosecution had not presented sufficient evidence to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt. They emphasized that criminal convictions must be based on certainty and credible evidence, not mere suspicion or conjecture. The key evidence presented during the trial was a series of WhatsApp screenshots shared by the complainant.

The defence, represented by Dr Hasan Elhais and Amal Al Rashedi Lawyers and Legal Consultants, questioned the reliability of these messages due to the unusual phone number format and suggested the screenshots might have been altered. Furthermore, they argued that the screenshots did not prove the woman's involvement in the conversations, nor did they provide forensic evidence confirming their origin from her phone.

The woman maintained she did not know the complainant and had never received any money from him, denying any involvement in the WhatsApp discussions attributed to her. The defence also contested the claim that the complainant had handed over money, pointing out that there was no receipt, bank transfer, or written agreement to support this assertion.

They argued that without evidence of this payment, it could not be proven that the woman had ever been in possession of the money under a legitimate trust arrangement. The appeal court further pointed out inconsistencies in the complainant's account of the transaction, questioning the legitimacy of the agency arrangement and the legitimacy of the money being transferred to the woman.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Read the original at gulfnews.com →

Report a problem with this story

More in World

More from Wednesday 7 October →