The strange new faces of Southeast Asian football leave fans bewildered
KUALA LUMPUR: The FIFA Asean Cup turned out to be a tournament of strange results and a naturalisation explosion, with many national teams losing their identity and fans struggling to connect with or relate to them.
KUALA LUMPUR: The FIFA Asean Cup showcased a peculiar set of results and a surge in naturalisation, leaving national teams feeling like overseas imports. Many teams resembled United Nations delegations, with foreign players representing their countries. Indonesia's squad consisted entirely of Dutch players, while the Philippines fielded 19 heritage players.
Malaysia had 12, nine of them naturalised, and three foreign-born. Vietnam and Bangladesh each had eight, Pakistan seven, Singapore five, and Thailand the fewest with three all naturalised. The question arises: is naturalisation inherently problematic, as seen with France and Morocco? Not necessarily, but it blurs the line between naturalisation and a lack of domestic talent.
France's player pool stems from centuries of immigration and a robust domestic football system, unlike Asean countries that lack sufficient grassroots development. When clubs sign players from anywhere, fans accept it. However, when fans watch Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, or the Philippines, they crave a connection to place, language, culture, and identity.
Naturalised players can become Malaysian, Indonesian, or Thai, but mass recruitment alters supporters' emotional ties to the national team. A Brazilian representing Malaysia and a Dutchman representing Indonesia engaged in a match against Asean nations. Bergson da Silva, the Malaysian top scorer with four goals, exemplifies this, yet stands out in his national colors.
Malaysia's 10 goals, seven from naturalised players, highlight the issue. The tournament's strange results added to the feeling that something was amiss. Malaysia beat Singapore 6-0, advancing to the final. However, Indonesia defeated Bangladesh 9-2, including two stoppage-time goals. Such outcomes only reinforced the notion that Asean football is becoming a platform for naturalised players, and national associations should tread carefully, ensuring the quick fix doesn't become the development strategy.
Written by urgent.news from New Straits Times's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.