Siblings win battle to secure inherited shares without need for fresh transfer
Beneficiaries can have shares registered in their names without executing transfer documents or paying stamp duty, court rules.
In a victory for inheritance rights, a Court of Appeal three-member panel ruled in favor of three siblings who sought to claim shares left to them by their late mother, without the need for fresh share-transfer paperwork or stamp duty payments. The case, heard in Putrajaya, centered on the shares held by Wong Kim, who passed away in 2015, and distributed among five beneficiaries, including her three children.
Initially, the executor of the estate made a transmission request to Toong Yuen (Ipoh) Sdn Bhd, the company holding the shares. However, the company rejected the request, claiming that the shares had already been transferred to the executor. The siblings appealed to the High Court, which dismissed their application.
On further review by the Court of Appeal, the bench, led by Justice Wong Kian Kheong, found that the shares were passed to the beneficiaries through transmission, a legal process that occurs by operation of law following a shareholder’s death and the grant of probate. The court emphasized that transmission and transfer are legally distinct, with transfer requiring an instrument of transfer and stamp duty payment.
The judgment also clarified that the Companies Act 2016 does not mandate the executor to transfer shares to beneficiaries, as transmission and transfer are governed by different legal principles. Furthermore, the court found that the company's articles governing share transfers did not apply to the shares' transmission, as these provisions were triggered by a formal transfer.
The ruling awarded the siblings RM50,000 in costs for the legal proceedings, with Elizabeth Lau and Hazel Siau representing the siblings and Rabinder Singh and Roshan Singh Dhaliwal representing Toong Yuen and the other respondents.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- Siblings win battle to secure inherited shares without need for fresh transfer freemalaysiatoday.com