Should AI pay taxes? The debate is gaining traction in the US
Bill Gates supports taxing the technology as progressive proposals grow to make new models make up for job destruction and other impacts
As the discussion surrounding AI safety intensifies, a new debate has emerged regarding whether artificial intelligence should be required to pay taxes. Bill Gates, co-founder of Microsoft, suggested that AI should contribute to pension funds by paying into Social Security on a "pay-as-you-go" basis, akin to how active workers support retired ones.
He questioned why a company that replaced human workers with robots should be exempt from contributing to the same pension system. Gates also raised concerns about the potential for tax laws to be manipulated to allow robots to avoid paying into the pension fund.
The issue of taxing AI activities has been debated for some time, but it is gaining momentum in the United States. Progressive lawmakers have introduced multiple proposals aimed at reducing tax benefits for AI labs or introducing direct taxes on their operations. While these initiatives have not yet gained significant traction, they could potentially become more viable as Democrats regain control of both chambers of Congress following the upcoming midterm elections.
Donald Trump, the current U.S. President, gathered leading AI company executives at the White House and suggested renaming the field to "superintelligence," while also expressing his reluctance to impose limitations on the development of these technologies. Instead, Trump supports self-regulation within the fiercely competitive sector.
Several legislative initiatives targeting AI taxation have been proposed, ranging from levies on data centers' energy consumption, computing hours, and robots, to taxes on the profits generated by these companies. For instance, a bipartisan group of three Democratic representatives—Greg Casar (Texas), Valerie Foushee (North Carolina), and Sara Jacobs (California)—introduced a proposal to tax AI companies and allocate the revenue towards an employment program to offset the technology's impact on the labor market.
Senator Bernie Sanders has proposed the creation of a special tax on AI companies, paid in shares rather than cash, until the government accumulates 50% of these companies' capital in a sovereign wealth fund. This levy would apply to companies generating at least $200 million in annual gross revenues from AI-related activities. Senator Elizabeth Warren also advocates for tax reform, calling for direct taxes on AI companies, including data centers, and imposing taxes on their negative externalities like water and energy consumption.
Warren has sent letters to executives of major AI labs, such as Meta, Amazon, Alphabet, and Microsoft, demanding transparency regarding tax incentives provided by the Trump administration and the construction of data centers. Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona has proposed three new taxes on AI, including one on digital advertising revenue, another on AI use in generated data, and a third on the windfall profits earned by AI companies, with the revenue earmarked for mitigating the technology's impact on the labor market.
Written by urgent.news from El Pais English's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.