High Court adjourns Solomon Asamoah and Christopher Akumfi trial awaiting Supreme Court decision
The Accra High Court has adjourned the trial of former GIIF CEO Solomon Asamoah to October 19 as the defence awaits a Supreme Court application ruling.
The Supreme Court began its new term on Monday by hearing a climate change case brought by the city of Boulder, Colorado, against oil companies ExxonMobil and Suncor. The case is one of many across the country in which local governments are suing fossil fuel companies for their role in climate change and seeking compensation for the resulting damages.
The high court's decision could impact the outcome of numerous similar cases and the notion that oil companies must bear the financial burden of the harm caused by their products.
During the questioning, justices demonstrated uncertainty about how they will rule, repeatedly emphasizing the difficulty of determining who is legally responsible for the consequences of climate change. While Boulder's case was initially filed in Colorado, the oil and gas companies argued that such matters belong at the federal level, seeking the Supreme Court's intervention.
The justices struggled to simplify the case, with some repeatedly questioning why the argument needed to be complex. However, they seldom agreed on the simplified argument. Some justices framed the case as one about emissions reduction, echoing ExxonMobil and Suncor's position. They argued that if Boulder's case aimed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, it could lead to states regulating emissions globally, which they deemed inappropriate.
The attorneys for the oil companies claimed the case would force oil and gas companies to pay for climate-related harms, potentially leading to the "bankruptcy" of some firms. They argued that the city could sue its own officials, such as the mayor, for driving a car that contributes to global climate change.
Boulder's legal team, on the other hand, didn't seek to stop oil and gas companies from producing fossil fuels or to prevent burning them. Instead, they argued that the companies deceived the public by claiming these products were not causing significant climate harms. They wanted the companies to pay for deceiving the public into believing that those products were harmless.
Justice Elena Kagan likened Boulder's case to lawsuits brought against tobacco companies in the 1990s, where states sought compensation for healthcare costs related to tobacco consumption. The companies were not required to stop selling cigarettes but were asked to roll back their pro-cigarette marketing and fund awareness campaigns about the effects of smoking.
The outcome of this case could set a precedent for future climate change lawsuits against fossil fuel companies, potentially opening the door for numerous similar cases seeking billions of dollars in damages. The court is expected to take months before issuing a decision.
Written by urgent.news from Grist's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- 2027: INEC confirms review of Supreme Court judgment affecting Chinda, Omo-Agege, others dailypost.ng
- INEC receives Certified True Copy of Supreme Court judgement on Electoral Act provisions premiumtimesng.com
- Supreme Court wrestles with who should pay for climate change grist.org
- Need to wait and see how far Supreme Court rectifies voter deletions: Omar Abdullah thehindu.com
- Steven Galloway defamation trial begins in B.C. Supreme Court cbc.ca
- Alito says Supreme Court can't stem rise of emergency appeals, 'not pleased' with Trump's rhetoric pbs.org
- Key points from the Supreme Court in the case against the oil companies. What is being judged? What are the repercussions? english.elpais.com
- Alito says Supreme Court can’t stem emergency appeals and voices concern over Trump’s rhetoric winnipegfreepress.com
