CCTV alone won't make schools safer, say parents' group and security expert [WATCH]
KUALA LUMPUR: The installation of closed-circuit television (CCTV) cameras at 1,000 schools next year will only improve student safety if it is supported by effective monitoring, supervision and reporting, said a parent’s advocacy group and a security expert.
KUALA LUMPUR: A parent advocacy group and a security expert have warned that installing CCTV cameras alone will not make schools safer in Malaysia. The Parent Action Group for Education Malaysia (PAGE) chairman, Datin Noor Azimah Abdul Rahim, and Munira Mustaffa, founder of security research firm Chasseur Group, both emphasized that CCTV cameras should complement, not replace, existing safety measures.
Noor Azimah stressed that the installation must be supported by effective monitoring, supervision, and reporting to ensure actual student safety.
While CCTV cameras can record incidents, they cannot replace supervision, reporting mechanisms, trained wardens, safety audits, and swift intervention, according to Noor Azimah. Munira added that CCTV cameras are not deterrents, but rather a means to provide evidence after a crime has occurred. She pointed out that the footage would only be useful in corroborating that a crime took place, but it would not prevent the crime from happening in the first place.
With the government allocating RM15 million for CCTV installations at 1,000 schools, the coverage will only reach less than 10 percent of the total schools in Malaysia. This raises concerns about the prioritization of schools and whether they have the necessary resources to monitor the footage. Munira highlighted that differences in monitoring capabilities between schools could create gaps in the system's effectiveness.
She also noted that CCTV cameras have limitations in detecting non-physical forms of harm, such as verbal bullying and sexual harassment, which could escalate into physical violence.
The experts concluded that the installation of CCTV cameras should not be seen as a complete solution to school safety issues. Instead, it should be combined with other measures to ensure a comprehensive approach to student safety.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.