Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

The crucial word missing from SA’s wildlife debate

South Africa’s bitter arguments over hunting, trade, captive breeding and the wildlife economy tend to revolve around ‘sustainable use’. But that shorthand leaves out a crucial word.

South Africa's wildlife debate often hinges on the phrase "sustainable use," yet this shorthand overlooks a critical term: "ecologically." Article 24 of the Constitution mandates the protection of the environment for present and future generations, requiring reasonable measures to prevent ecological degradation and promote conservation. This implies that natural resource use must occur within ecological limits.

While wildlife-based enterprises can generate jobs, income, and economic value, the crucial question is whether these activities protect wild populations, genetic diversity, ecological processes, and functioning ecosystems. Simply generating revenue or creating jobs does not guarantee sustainable use.

The Constitution, therefore, does not grant an unrestricted right to use wildlife. Instead, wildlife enterprises must demonstrate ecological sustainability. This means that activities should not contribute to the long-term decline of biodiversity, genetic integrity, or the ecological integrity of ecosystems.

Climate change further emphasizes the importance of ecological sustainability. Degraded ecosystems that wildlife and people depend on will eventually lead to economic failures. Thus, ecological sustainability should be the first test for any wildlife activity.

The government's White Paper on Conservation and Sustainable Use of South Africa's Biodiversity, 2023, offers a practical definition of sustainable use: the use of biodiversity that is ecologically, economically, and socially sustainable without contributing to the long-term decline of biodiversity, disrupting genetic integrity, or damaging ecological integrity.

In conclusion, responsible use can be a valuable conservation tool, but it must meet clear ecological, ethical, and social boundaries. Activities should maintain or restore ecological integrity, support viable wild populations, protect genetic diversity, ensure humane treatment, fairly share benefits, and be effectively regulated. Only when these criteria are met can wildlife use be considered sustainable.

Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at dailymaverick.co.za →

More in World

More from Monday 5 October →