SIR row: Will annul EC orders not in keeping with law, says Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has asked the Election Commission to clarify decision-making processes related to voter roll revisions. It emphasized that decisions should be taken unanimously or by majority among commission members only. Senior advocate Vikas Singh argued for preserving records and scrutiny of the commission's actions. The court will examine allegations of unilateral actions against the Chief…
The Supreme Court has issued notices to the Centre and the Election Commission of India (ECI) over allegations that Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar acted unilaterally, potentially violating laws governing his terms of office. The three-judge bench, led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, is also directing its inquiry at ECI members Sukhbir Singh Sandhu, Vivek Joshi, Deputy Election Commissioner Maneesh Garg and ECI Director General (Information Technology) Seema Khanna.
The petition, filed by Patna resident Rakesh Kumar Singh, was based on revelations from an investigation by The Indian Express, published on September 23, which highlighted that Sandhu and Joshi had objected on 14 occasions in 10 months to actions taken by the Commission. These objections ranged from keeping them uninformed to the addition of new voters and the deletion of names from the electoral rolls.
The petition urged the court to request the "complete original and primary records" related to the matter from the ECI and to declare the ongoing procedure illegal. The court, comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, was asked to examine these records and determine if decisions taken without unanimous or majority consensus should be annulled.
However, the court did not issue any interim orders to suspend Kumar or direct the ECI to take decisions unanimously. Senior Advocate Vikas Singh, representing the petitioner, argued for such interim relief, stating that elections in progress could be jeopardized and that the very credibility of democracy was at risk. He suggested the court restore the ECI's position as a member of the selection committee for CEC.
Singh emphasized the gravity of the situation, suggesting that failure to pass interim measures would cause grave consequences for democracy. Despite the court's reluctance to issue interim orders, Singh pressed for the ECI to make decisions unanimously until the court's next hearing. The court, however, clarified that decisions must first follow the law, which mandates unanimity or majority consensus.
The CJI assured that the court would ensure adherence to these legal principles, even if it leads to the annulment of decisions that do not meet these criteria.
Written by urgent.news from The Indian Express's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- Supreme Court may get 3 judges today, to be one short of full strength timesofindia.indiatimes.com
- Alito slams criticism of Supreme Court from political leaders, says it can be "quite damaging" cbsnews.com
- ‘Deleted voter filing Form 6 not false declaration’: Election Commission tells Bombay High Court amid SIR row hindustantimes.com
- The knock on the Supreme Court’s door indianexpress.com