Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

Malaysian Bar fails bid to challenge Terrirudin's appointment to JAC

Nothing in appointment was illogical or contrary to accepted moral standards, court rules.

Malaysian Bar fails bid to challenge Terrirudin's appointment to JAC

KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Bar's attempt to contest Tan Sri Ahmad Terrirudin Mohd Salleh's appointment to the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) was unsuccessful. High Court judge Norliza Othman rejected the Bar's request for leave to commence judicial review proceedings, determining that the challenge was not legally viable.

She held that Section 5(1)(e) of the Judicial Appointments Commission Act was unambiguous, mandating merely that the appointee be a serving Federal Court judge deemed suitable by the Prime Minister. The court found both conditions to be met in Terrirudin's appointment. Norliza contended that the Bar was urging the court to infer extra requirements, such as seniority, length of service, prior High Court or Court of Appeal experience, absence of unresolved allegations, and adherence to an alleged convention.

None of these criteria were mentioned in the Act. The court also dismissed the Bar's claims that the appointment was unlawful and unreasonable, asserting that it was made in accordance with the law. With regard to irrationality, the court noted that the appointment made logical sense and was not contrary to accepted moral standards.

In terms of locus standi, the court found the Malaysian Bar's concern about being adversely affected insufficient under Order 53 Rule 2(4) of the Rules of Court. The court concluded that the JAC merely recommends candidates for judicial appointments, while the appointment power rests with the Yang di-Pertuan Agong on the Prime Minister's advice under Article 122B of the Federal Constitution.

The court dismissed suspicions of bias arising from the commission's composition as remote, indirect, and speculative. The Malaysian Bar submitted its leave application on February 12, naming Terrirudin, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, the JAC, and the government as respondents. The Bar sought a certiorari order to annul Anwar's decision to appoint Terrirudin as a JAC member and a mandamus order directing the establishment of a royal commission of inquiry to investigate allegations against Terrirudin.

Written by urgent.news from New Straits Times's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

This story

This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.

Every outlet that reported this, and when →

Read the original at malaysiakini.com →

More in World

More from Monday 5 October →