Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

Ex-CJI Gavai, Former Judges Question Justice Bhuyan’s Remarks On Electoral Roll Revision

Former Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and two retired Delhi High Court judges have criticised Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan’s remarks on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, arguing that a sitting judge should avoid commenting publicly on a matter pending before the apex court. Justice Bhuyan, delivering the valedictory address at the 19th Justice Bodh Raj Sawhney…

Ex-CJI Gavai, Former Judges Question Justice Bhuyan’s Remarks On Electoral Roll Revision

Former Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and retired Delhi High Court judges S N Dhingra and R S Sodhi have criticised Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan's remarks on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The judges argue that a sitting judge should avoid commenting publicly on a matter pending before the apex court.

Bhuyan, in his valedictory address at NALSAR University of Law, said any process that "disenfranchises" millions of Indian citizens was "intrinsically arbitrary" and a "negation" of the constitutional order. Gavai questioned the propriety of a judge making such statements on a matter sub judice, arguing that a sitting Supreme Court judge should not publicly comment on issues awaiting adjudication.

Dhingra and Sodhi echoed Gavai's concerns, criticizing Bhuyan's comments as going "way beyond the limits of a sitting top court judge" and questioning whether he fully understood the facts of the issue. The judges also challenged Bhuyan's assertion that the SIR process disenfranchises millions of citizens, arguing that voting rights are governed by statutory law.

They emphasized that the legal process should be followed to determine whether an individual's name should remain on the electoral roll, rather than making sweeping statements about the rights of citizens. The SIR issue is currently under review by the Supreme Court, with pleas concerning its validity and the selection of Election Commissioners among the pending cases.

Bhuyan, who previously served as Chancellor of NALSAR University of Law, praised the university's law students during his address, commending their brilliance, boldness, and bravery.

Written by urgent.news from Free Press Journal's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Also reported by 1 other outlet

Every outlet that reported this, and when →

Read the original at freepressjournal.in →

More in World

More from Monday 5 October →