Courts aren’t rubber stamps for consent orders, says Court of Appeal
Bench says parties must ensure the court has the jurisdiction and power to record settlements.
The Court of Appeal clarified that it does not function as a rubber stamp for recording consent orders and judgments, informing litigants and lawyers that they must first verify the court's jurisdiction and authority before requesting it to record a settlement. This reminder emerged in a judgment issued by Justice Wong Kian Kheong alongside Justices Firuz Jaffril and Leonard David Shim, addressing an appeal by Noble Energy Construction Sdn Bhd against a High Court decision to wind up the company.
The High Court had previously mandated Noble Energy's dissolution and appointed the official receiver as liquidator, following a dispute over a RM864,218.63 unpaid construction debt. Sim Soon Construction & Trading had petitioned for Noble Energy's winding up. During the appeal process, both parties ultimately reached an agreement for Noble Energy to pay Sim Soon RM420,000 as a full and final resolution of their disagreement.
However, the Court of Appeal declined to record the consent order, ruling that it lacked the power to do so in this context. Justice Wong emphasized that the High Court itself had no authority under Section 469 of the Companies Act 2016 to issue monetary orders within winding-up proceedings, as the winding-up process is a statutory mechanism for addressing insolvent companies, not a method for debt collection.
Furthermore, the Court of Appeal determined that Section 69 of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964 did not confer upon it any authority that the High Court did not already possess. Consequently, the bench chose not to record the RM420,000 settlement and allowed Noble Energy's appeal to proceed on its substantive merits. Asmawi Ismail and Nur Asnani Basharuddin represented Noble Energy, while Kenneth Liew acted on behalf of Sim Soon.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- SJC announces completion of 50% of new designs for Courts Complex, Court of Cassation thepeninsulaqatar.com
- SJC announces completion of 50% of new designs for Courts Complex, Court of Cassation gulf-times.com
- Courts aren’t rubber stamps for consent orders, says Court of Appeal freemalaysiatoday.com