Capital punishment only possible if reformation of convict is ruled out: Supreme Court
The bench criticised the trial court for imposing the death sentence on the same day as conviction without a separate hearing on punishment.
The Supreme Court has ruled that the death penalty can only be imposed in cases where a convict's potential for reformation is entirely ruled out, emphasizing that a crime's brutality alone is not sufficient to warrant capital punishment. The bench of Justices Vikram Nath, Sandeep Mehta, and Vijay Bishnoi stated that the prosecution must prove life imprisonment is insufficient as an alternative, and the death sentence should only be reserved for instances where life imprisonment is demonstrably out of the question.
The court highlighted the need to distinguish between the gravity of a crime and the convict's capacity for reform. Applying this principle, the court commuted the death sentence of a man convicted of repeatedly sexually assaulting and murdering his six-year-old stepdaughter in 2018, ruling that imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life without remission was an appropriate punishment given the severity of the crime.
The court noted that while the crime was brutal, it did not automatically establish the convict's irredeemability. Several mitigating factors were considered, including the offender's background, lack of prior criminal history, satisfactory conduct in custody, and strong family ties. The trial court had erroneously combined the conviction and sentencing on the same day, violating legal procedures.
The Supreme Court obtained additional information on the offender's social and psychological background to ensure a comprehensive assessment of the sentencing decision.
Written by urgent.news from Hindustan Times's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
Other reports of this story
- Killer beetles, tinderbox forests: Climate change costs center stage at Supreme Court abcnews.com
- Supreme Court notice to ECI, Centre on plea challenging decisions taken by CEC-led poll panel thehindu.com
- Great Nicobar project: Supreme Court rejects govt’s plea, fast-tracks HC scrutiny hindustantimes.com
- A new Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights winnipegfreepress.com
- After Express report, Supreme Court notice to Centre on Central Secretariat Library relocation indianexpress.com