Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

Can Pakistan-Israel ties exist? Yes, if the perpetual Palestinian conflict ends – opinion

Islamabad could come to terms with Israel’s existence when Palestinians are safe in a state of their own.

Pakistan's relationship with Israel remains a complex issue, rooted in decades of political tensions. Islamabad does not recognize the Jewish state and ties any shift in ties to the creation of an independent Palestinian state. However, as the international community continues to push for a two-state solution based on pre-1967 borders, with East Jerusalem as the future capital of Palestine, Pakistan's stance on the matter may evolve.

The question of whether Pakistan can support Palestinian rights while acknowledging Israel's right to exist as a permanent reality in the Middle East warrants careful consideration. The answer, however, seems to be yes. A just peace does not necessitate Pakistan foregoing its support for Palestine, nor does it require Israel to surrender its security concerns.

Israelis have lived in the region for centuries, with strong historical and religious ties to the land. Their security is unquestionably valid, just as Palestinians' right to self-determination and statehood is equally legitimate.

Israel's existence cannot be denied, and Israeli citizens must endure the fear and insecurity stemming from ongoing conflicts and terrorism. Yet, this reality does not automatically invalidate the need for a peaceful resolution. Pakistan can simultaneously affirm that Palestinians deserve freedom, dignity, and statehood, while also recognizing Israel's right to security and a life free from constant threat.

Pakistan's stance on the Palestinian issue is deeply embedded in its foreign policy and public consciousness. Islamabad has consistently advocated for an independent, sovereign Palestinian state as a cornerstone of any just peace. Any discussion suggesting "recognize Israel and forget Palestine" would be seen as illogical in Pakistan. The Palestinian issue cannot be relegated to the background; instead, it must be addressed alongside Israel's security concerns.

The true challenge lies in finding a framework in which both peoples can coexist with a sense of security and dignity. Diplomatic communication does not imply political surrender; countries often engage with governments they disagree with through various channels. Pakistan could explore controlled communication, humanitarian exchanges, academic interactions, trade, and technology partnerships without abandoning its commitment to Palestinian statehood.

Pakistan is increasingly positioning itself as a contributor to regional diplomacy, participating in multilateral Gaza efforts alongside multiple nations in 2026. However, its position is not simply "no"; Islamabad has not declared Palestinian statehood and has maintained that relationships with other countries, including potentially Israel, could be considered. Diplomacy often begins when a country stops insisting that every future possibility is closed.

A realistic road map for possible future relations between Pakistan and Israel should involve gradual steps such as indirect dialogue through third parties, humanitarian and technical exchanges, academic collaborations, and civil society interactions. Only after these steps have been explored should formal recognition be considered. Pakistan must acknowledge the real security concerns of Israel, while Israel must recognize the fundamental relationship between Pakistan and Palestine.

Peace cannot be merely the absence of fighting; it requires the creation of political settlements that address the concerns of both peoples. Ceasefires merely stop bullets; political settlements change the conditions of life for Israelis and Palestinians alike. Pakistan should advocate for a realistic approach that acknowledges both Israel's security needs and Palestinians' aspirations for freedom and self-determination.

Pakistanis should engage in discussions about Israel without being accused of abandoning Palestine, and Israelis should discuss Palestinian rights without being accused of forsaking Israel. The mature conversation of a future peace must not ask people to forget their history but refrain from becoming prisoners of it.

The first step towards a more constructive dialogue is simply having a conversation. Pakistan does not need to rush into formal recognition, nor does it need to close its doors forever. The path to peace involves creating a space for dialogue while maintaining support for Palestinian self-determination. Only when a credible pathway to Palestinian statehood is established, Israel's security concerns are addressed, and both sides prepare to coexist, can Pakistan reassess its stance.

This approach is not betrayal, but rather a form of diplomacy. A just peace offers both peoples a future where security, dignity, and human life are shared responsibilities, and that future is worth discussing.

Written by urgent.news from Jerusalem Post's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at jpost.com →

More in World

More from Monday 5 October →