Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

'First Decide Assessee’s Objections, Then Reopen Completed Tax Assessment': Bombay HC

Mumbai, October 3, 2026: The Bombay High Court has held that the Income Tax Department cannot begin reassessment proceedings until it first decides an assessee’s objections to reopening a completed tax assessment, stressing that the prescribed procedure must be followed before scrutiny can commence. The ruling came while quashing reassessment notices issued to diamond trading firm H.P. Diamonds…

'First Decide Assessee’s Objections, Then Reopen Completed Tax Assessment': Bombay HC

Mumbai, October 3, 2026: The Bombay High Court has ruled that the Income Tax Department must first address an assessee's objections before initiating reassessment proceedings following a completed tax assessment. The decision came while overturning reassessment notices issued to the diamond trading firm H.P. Diamonds India Pvt. Ltd. for the 2012-13 assessment year.

According to the ruling, initiating scrutiny before resolving objections is improper. The dispute emerged after the department issued a notice in March 2019 seeking to reopen the company's assessment over share premium transactions. However, the Assessing Officer had already issued a scrutiny notice before giving reasons for reopening.

The company subsequently filed objections in October 2019, which were dismissed by the Assessing Officer on October 31. The department then sought further information through a notice on November 12. H.P. Diamonds' lawyer argued that the department had not adhered to the Supreme Court's procedure, stating that objections should be decided before proceeding with reassessment.

The Revenue lawyer countered that the requirement only prevented the department from passing a final assessment order without deciding objections. The court disagreed, ruling that issuing a Section 143(2) Notice marks the start of assessment proceedings, and objections must be resolved first. The bench emphasized that issuing a notice and proceeding with assessment without resolving objections is "putting the cart before the horse."

The court also noted the department's failure to adhere to the mandatory four-week period after rejecting objections before taking further steps. As a result, the High Court quashed the notices and reassessment proceedings.

Written by urgent.news from Free Press Journal's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at freepressjournal.in →

More in World

More from Saturday 3 October →