Federal judge rules warrantless Flock camera searches may violate 4th Amendment
An Oklahoma federal judge ruled Friday that warrantless searches using AI-powered surveillance camera data, such as what Flock Safety's hallmark technology collects, may violate the Fourth Amendment without adequate probable cause. “Freedom from persistent, dragnet-style surveillance while in public is not a foreign concept in our society, and it is a reasonable expectation that society...
US District Judge Sara E. Hill in Oklahoma has expressed new Fourth Amendment concerns regarding the use of Flock Safety's license-plate data by law enforcement. The ruling focuses on a single police search, but it carries broader implications for privacy and surveillance. Judge Hill ruled that a Tulsa County sheriff's deputy violated the Fourth Amendment when he searched a vehicle's historical location data through Flock and a license-plate reader system without a warrant.
The search produced over 50 sightings of the vehicle across multiple states within a month. The case involved a woman with California-issued plates. Judge Hill stated that allowing the government to collect and review a person's movements over time can create a serious privacy issue, as it may lead to undisciplined and passive cataloging of an individual's whereabouts.
However, the decision does not ban Flock cameras or prevent police departments from using ALPR technology. Instead, it applies to the specific search in the Oklahoma case, holding that the deputy's search lacked probable cause and violated the driver's Fourth Amendment rights. The ruling orders the suppression of evidence obtained through the Flock search.
Flock Safety has contested the decision, claiming it conflicts with other court rulings and expects an appeal. This case comes amid broader debate over privacy and police surveillance, with lawmakers from both parties calling for limits on the technology and some states and local governments restricting or ending its use.
Written by urgent.news from Hindustan Times - World News's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.