Why media fans want to escape algorithms with CDs, DVDs and vinyl

Physical media, such as CDs, DVDs, and vinyl records, have experienced a resurgence as people seek to escape the algorithmically curated content of streaming platforms. This return to physical formats stems from a desire to protect data, support artists, and retain control over their media choices.

For some, the appeal lies in the security and permanence of owning a physical copy of their favorite films and music, free from interruptions and the potential deletion of streaming content. Ash, a university lecturer from Cornwall, explains that while streaming algorithms can suggest music, it often feels like "catching small fish," while curating music through physical media allows for a more substantial discovery process.

CJ, a compliance manager from Atlanta, cites instances where her favorite shows were removed from streaming services, highlighting the risk of losing access to media. This led her to return to physical media for a sense of ownership and control over her content. Ruth, a retired professor from Michigan, emphasizes the importance of owning her music and supporting musicians. She has amassed over 5,300 CDs and rents physical film titles by mail due to unreliable internet access in their rural area.

Antonio, a software engineer in Reading, switched to buying secondhand CDs to avoid the reliance on subscription services and the associated price increases. Quinn, a 26-year-old food delivery worker in Washington, began collecting cassette tapes to support artists while dealing with a busy schedule that limited his concert attendance. The tactile nature of physical media also provides a sense of ritual and engagement that appeals to him.

The shift to physical formats is driven by a desire for choice and independence from algorithms. Tim, an academic in Stockholm, appreciates the middle stage between digital and analog media, enjoying the setup process and the slowness of it all. Sophie, a librarian in Los Angeles, opts for physical CDs and DVDs due to her aversion to algorithms. All these individuals share a common goal: to reclaim control over their media consumption and enjoy the content they choose.