New Mexico wants Meta to pay up to $40 billion in penalties after data privacy trial
The state of New Mexico asked a judge on Thursday to order Meta Platforms to pay between $35 billion and $40 billion in penalties after a jury found the company had misled consumers about the privacy of their data on Facebook in a case that came out of the Cambridge Analytica scandal.
New Mexico has petitioned a judge to order Meta Platforms to pay between $35 billion and $40 billion in penalties following a jury's conclusion that the company had misled consumers about the privacy of their data on Facebook. The litigation stems from the Cambridge Analytica scandal, in which a British political consulting firm harvested personal data from up to 87 million Facebook users through a third-party app without their consent.
Judge Francis Mathew, who presided over the trial in Santa Fe, will determine the exact amount Meta must pay in financial penalties. During a hearing, attorneys for both parties debated the appropriate penalty, with Meta arguing that the state's requested amount does not accurately reflect the misconduct highlighted in the trial.
Mathew countered that once a trial is taken to court, defendants must accept the repercussions of their decision to proceed with litigation. The lawsuit, filed in 2021, accused Meta of deceiving Facebook users in New Mexico about who had access to their data, Meta's stance on hate speech and misinformation, and other internal policies.
Jurors assessed 29 statements made by the company and its executives on these topics and found 26 of them to be misleading. The state asserts that Meta knew third parties had extensive access to users' personal data and tolerated harmful content when it aligned with the company's financial interests. Meta's legal team countered that the statements were cherry-picked excerpts, and the company had consistently acknowledged its shortcomings in handling misinformation or privacy concerns.
State law permits the judge to decide the penalty per violation, up to $5,000. Randi McGinn, representing New Mexico, argued that imposing the full $5,000 fine on the number of violations would be excessive under US constitutional protections on due process. However, she proposed a significant fine of $35 billion to $40 billion, which would still impact Meta's stock price while adhering to due process rights.
In contrast, Meta's lawyer, Matt Nicholson, denounced the state's request as an "astronomical penalty" that would violate constitutional provisions. Meta contended that the jury's finding of misleading statements did not prove that any consumer had actually been deceived, nor did they prove that Meta sold user data, as highlighted in their court filings. The judge indicated he would issue a ruling later in the month.
Written by urgent.news from MyJoyOnline Ghana's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- New Mexico asks a judge to order Meta to pay up to $40B after a jury found it willfully deceived customers, in what could be the biggest US court penalty ever (KRQE) krqe.com
- Dutch eyewear chain pauses Meta glasses sales amid privacy concerns indianexpress.com
- New Mexico wants Meta to pay up to $40 billion in penalties after data privacy trial channelnewsasia.com