Listed firm can’t disguise dismissal as redesignation, says court
Justice Alice Loke upholds RM756,000 award to a former senior executive, saying Minetech Resources Bhd clearly ended his employment.
In a recent ruling, the Kuala Lumpur High Court has dismissed Minetech Resources Bhd's attempt to argue that the dismissal of former executive director of finance, Abdul Farid Abdul Kadir, was merely a redesignation. Justice Alice Loke upheld an RM756,000 award issued by the Industrial Court to Kadir, stating that the company's own letter clearly terminated his employment.
Minetech Resources, now known as Aizo Group Bhd, had sought a judicial review application to challenge the award, but the court dismissed the application and ordered the company to pay Kadir RM10,000 in costs. The court rejected the company's contention that Kadir's appointment as a non-independent non-executive director in November 2020 was a re-designation, emphasizing that the company's notice letter, combined with Kadir's letter of appointment, clearly indicated the termination of his employment.
Kadir was appointed as executive director of finance in June 2020, receiving a monthly salary of RM45,000 along with allowances. The company's board later redesignated him as a non-independent non-executive director in November 2020, reducing his remuneration to a RM3,000 director's fee. Three days following this redesignation, Minetech informed Kadir that his employment as executive director of finance had ceased, offering him RM128,330.77 in lieu of notice. Kadir deemed this action as a dismissal without just cause or excuse.
The Industrial Court found Kadir's dismissal to be unjustified and awarded him the RM756,000. However, Minetech argued that Kadir remained an employee and was only removed from his directorial position during an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) in June 2021. Justice Loke rejected this argument, asserting that the EGM pertained to Kadir's removal as a director and did not alter the prior termination of his employment.
Additionally, she noted that there was no evidence supporting Minetech's claim of poor performance, as no warning letters or evidence of Kadir's alleged shortcomings or job scope were presented before the Industrial Court.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- Listed firm can’t disguise dismissal as redesignation, says court freemalaysiatoday.com