Consumers Trust Their Jobs as Savings Run Thin

Despite consumers maintaining confidence in their jobs, a dwindling savings reserve is reshaping the financial landscape they navigate, according to the September 2026 PYMNTS Consumer Expectations Index report titled "Consumers Hold the Line as Their Financial Cushion Shrinks." The index revealed that overall consumer confidence slipped by 0.7 points to 54.1, marking the second consecutive monthly decline.

However, this decrease was primarily observed in perceptions of the economy, purchasing conditions, and job mobility. Notably, measures of personal financial resilience remained relatively stable, while consumer confidence in job security persisted at a high level. The implications of this shift are clear: consumers, while still economically stable, possess less financial cushion to withstand unforeseen disruptions.

In terms of payments, this dynamic underscores the growing significance of available funds, as dwindling savings offer limited protection against financial setbacks. Key findings highlighted that 8% of consumers now have savings that could sustain them for three months or less if their income ceased, a 2.4 percentage point increase from August and a 4.0 percentage point rise from April.

Conversely, the proportion of consumers with more than a year of savings dwindled to 15.1%, marking the lowest level in the past year. Job security, as gauged by a measure of personal job security, remained steady at 4, indicating a lack of significant change during the month. Additionally, perceived safety from layoffs improved by 1.3 points to 71.9.

Meanwhile, job mobility, which assesses consumers' ability to find a new job that meets their financial needs, dipped by 2.2 points to 9. Every income tier tracked by PYMNTS experienced a decline in job mobility during the month. This contrast between job security and job mobility offers insight into the current consumer perspective: individuals remain confident in their current employment while harboring less confidence in their capacity to secure new employment if necessary.

This distinction becomes especially pertinent as households contend with rising expenses through savings that may not suffice as they once did. The report also indicated that 85% of consumers reported an increase in essential expenses over the past year, coinciding with a 2.2-point decline in the Macroeconomic and Buying Climate subindex, which evaluates perceptions of the economy and the timing of major purchases.

Personal Financial Resilience, encompassing savings, debt, and day-to-day financial management, held steady at 58.3. Notably, confidence in saving among baby boomers and seniors rose by 3.6 points, while Generation Z saw a decline of 1.3 points in this measure. Overall sentiment saw the steepest decline among Generation Z and Generation X. In summary, this report illuminates a consumer landscape where financial management continues amidst a narrower buffer against unexpected costs.

For payment providers, this environment emphasizes the heightened importance of money movement and availability within consumers' broader financial lives. Payments play a crucial role in this narrative, offering consumers faster and more transparent financial interactions at a time when the perception of personal financial situations holds greater significance.

PYMNTS Intelligence collaborates with businesses to unveil insights that inform intelligent, data-driven discussions on evolving customer expectations, a more connected economy, and the strategic transformations required to achieve desired outcomes. Through rigorous research methodologies and an unwavering commitment to objective quality, PYMNTS Intelligence provides trusted data to support business growth.

As a valued partner, PYMNTS Intelligence offers access to a diverse team of experts, including PhDs, researchers, data analysts, number crunchers, subject matter veterans, and editorial professionals.