GM Jon-Eric Sullivan looking at tough decision if Dolphins pick No. 1

The Miami Dolphins could potentially own the No. 1 overall pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, according to ESPN, with a 46% likelihood heading into Week 3 of the 2026 season. General Manager Jon-Eric Sullivan is facing a difficult choice if the Dolphins secure that top position, as he will need to decide which player to select. Two of the most likely options are quarterback Arch Manning and defensive end Colin Simmons, both of whom are potential top-five picks in the 2027 draft.

Manning, a highly-touted recruit, has some uncertainty surrounding his decision to enter the draft. Some believe he may still need more time to develop at the collegiate level, while others consider him the clear-cut No. 1 pick. In the game against Tennessee, Manning threw for 201 yards and completed 14 of his 19 passes, but his interception was questionable due to a deep pass into double coverage.

On the other hand, Simmons had a standout performance in the same game, recording a team-record five sacks, eight tackles (four for loss), a quarterback hit, and a forced fumble. His impressive play led to him being the main attraction for many observers. Manning, however, remains the primary subject of debate, with pundits and social media expressing mixed opinions on his positioning for the top pick.

Adding further complexity to the decision, Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith had a phenomenal day in Columbus, Ohio, with 12 catches for 217 yards and four touchdowns. If the Dolphins have the top pick, they could add a potential franchise player like Smith to their roster, along with other options like Collins or Manning. However, the Dolphins could also explore trading down to secure a player like Collins or Smith, as well as considering the impact of current quarterback Malik Willis on their future plans.