What survives the smoke: From New York’s memorial to Jerusalem’s living future - opinion
Hopefully, one day, the friendship between New York and Jerusalem will be repaired. But whatever politicians decide, our future will not be determined in City Hall.
On a recent trip to Jerusalem, a community tour group stopped at the 9/11 Living Memorial Plaza, an extraordinary site that pays tribute to the nearly 3,000 people murdered during the September 11 attacks. Embedded in the base of the monument is a piece of metal recovered from the Twin Towers, a physical reminder of the connection between New York and Jerusalem.
One inscription caught the reporter's attention, stating, "This metal piece, like the entire monument, is a manifestation of the special relationship between New York and Jerusalem." This sentiment, while intended to be timeless, now appears almost dated after witnessing the political changes in New York. The reporter drew a parallel to an ancient verse from Exodus, "A new king arose over Egypt who did not know Joseph," reminding us of the forgotten contributions of individuals and the dangers of amnesia.
In the years following the October 7 attacks, New York witnessed a significant shift in its relationship with Israel. Jewish students faced hostility on campuses, and Zionism became a term of abuse. The city's mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has accused Israel of genocide, refused to affirm its right to exist as a Jewish state, and distanced himself from the city's Israel parade. These actions represent a stark departure from the city's long-standing commitment to Israel.
The metal piece embedded in the monument remains fixed in Jerusalem stone, but the political relationship it symbolized no longer seems as solid. Its flame now represents something precious lost to politics. However, the reporter's journey did not end at the memorial; they continued to the Old City for slihot, a celebration filled with joy, unity, and a sense of belonging among Jews from diverse backgrounds.
Despite the political turmoil in New York, the reporter found hope in Jerusalem. The streets were filled with young Jews singing, dancing, praying, and enjoying each other's company. Regardless of religious observance, age, or background, everyone came together in slihot, acknowledging their shared Jewish identity and pride in Jerusalem.
This scene contrasted sharply with the somber atmosphere of the 9/11 Living Memorial Plaza, highlighting the fragility of political alliances and the enduring strength of the Jewish people.
Written by urgent.news from Jerusalem Post's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
