‘Up Against It’ Review: A Toothless Rom-Com Misfire With an Overqualified Antonio Banderas

“Up Against It,” Trudie Styler’s latest rom-com, stands out as a peculiar film. Its narrative centers on a child's cancer diagnosis as a catalyst for a tale about love and the challenges of parenting. While the cast is certainly talented, their efforts are somewhat undermined by the film's problematic material. The movie appears to be unfinished, with noticeable rough edges that detract from its overall cohesiveness.

Styler, with her previous rom-coms, had the potential to delve into complex issues like divorce, betrayal, and family dynamics. However, these elements feel more like an afterthought, as the characters pay lip service to them without truly exploring them. The story follows a separated couple, Álvaro (Antonio Banderas) and Saffron (Eva Birthistle), who have moved on with new partners.

Their daughter, Rose (Eden Hamilton), is diagnosed with a rare form of leukemia, which can only be treated by a blood transfusion from a genetic match. In an effort to save Rose, Álvaro and Saffron decide to try IVF, leading to a conflict with their current partners. The film's decision to focus on the IVF process is commendable, as it raises thought-provoking questions about creating new life to save an existing one.

However, the execution falls short, as the film fails to fully explore these complex themes. Despite the strong performances from Banderas and Birthistle, who bring depth to their characters, the film's humor often feels forced and misplaced. The presence of a doctor (Selena Tan) who jokingly offers relationship advice only adds to the film's awkward tone.

While there are moments of genuine emotion, such as when Álvaro and Saffron's partners support Rose during her hair loss, they are often overshadowed by the film's relentless attempts at humor. Styler's attempt to create a more inclusive rom-com family dynamic is appreciated, as it acknowledges that not all families are the same.

However, the film ultimately fails to fully embrace its potential, opting instead to mask its true intentions with awkward humor. In the end, "Up Against It" feels like a missed opportunity, with an overqualified cast and a promising premise, but a lack of vulnerability and honesty that would have truly resonated with audiences.