Five key questions for Thomas Tuchel and England this international break, from Jordan Pickford to 'DNA'

Five key questions for Thomas Tuchel and England this international break, from Jordan Pickford to DNA originally appeared on The Sporting News. England clinched a third-place finish at the 2026 World Cup, their best result since the 1966 World Cup triumph. However, Tuchel's team struggled late in the tournament, culminating in a 2-1 semifinal loss to Argentina in Atlanta. This raises several questions for the manager and the national team as they prepare for the UEFA Nations League.

Firstly, have the scars of the Argentina defeat truly healed? Manager Tuchel acknowledged his responsibility for the loss during a post-tournament documentary, stating that he takes ownership of the situation. However, it remains to be seen whether the wounds from that defeat have fully healed, and if Tuchel can regain his authority as a coach.

Secondly, can the midfield overcome England's "DNA"? After the World Cup, Tuchel suggested that ball possession is crucial, but it is not in England's DNA like it is in Spain or Argentina to control the game with possession. England's recent defeats to technically superior opponents have followed a pattern of losing control of the ball and eventually being overwhelmed. Tuchel must convince the team to overcome this perceived "DNA" and play more effectively.

Thirdly, can Jordan Pickford still be considered the undisputed No. 1 goalkeeper? Pickford was instrumental in England's deep runs in World Cups and Euro 2020 and Euro 2024, notably scoring a penalty in the 2020 tournament. However, at the 2026 World Cup, Pickford was skittish and less effective. With James Trafford currently at Leeds United and having a locked-in No. 1 spot, Pickford's position as the primary goalkeeper is under scrutiny.

Fourthly, is there an alternative to Harry Kane as England's captain? Kane has been a consistent performer for England and Bayern Munich, but his World Cup performance showed signs of fading as the tournament progressed. While Kane remains the most likely candidate to lead England to further success, there is a need for a workable alternative if Kane's physical capabilities decline over the next few years.

Lastly, how will the World Cup outcasts be reintegrated into the squad? Tuchel's selection for the 2026 World Cup saw several high-quality players left out, including some who were not comfortable full-backs. However, the manager frequently spoke about the "brotherhood" created during England's successful run in Mexico City. The reintroduction of players like Joelinton, Trent Alexander-Arnold, and Joelinton could provide a boost to the team, but Tuchel's decision-making process in the first place has come under scrutiny.