Elon Musk’s Grok AI contest awards $100k to ‘historically accurate’ version of The Odyssey — but it features a 3-eyed Cyclops and hilarious physics fails
There are some reasonably impressive visuals in this 5-minute shortened down take on The Odyssey, as well as lots of issues.
Elon Musk's AI project, Grok Imagine, has awarded $100,000 to filmmaker Nem Perez for crafting a "historically accurate" version of Homer's epic poem, The Odyssey. The winner's five-minute video features at least a minute of dialogue and emphasizes Odysseus's tale to Princess Nausicaa, a detail present in Homer's work but absent from the Christopher Nolan adaptation.
The second place ($50,000) was claimed by @JSFILMZ0412 for an extended ending depicting an elderly Odysseus passing his knowledge to future generations. The third place ($25,000) went to @Mr_AllenT, who reimagined the Cyclops cave scene as a horror movie scenario.
While AI-generated video has advanced significantly, experts still believe it falls short of genuine filmmaking. The winning video displayed common AI video flaws, such as inconsistent physics, inconsistent costumes, and a generic AI appearance. Additionally, elements like swords, trees, faces, and monsters appeared somewhat smooth, which can be attributed to training the AI on millions of hours of human-made video footage.
The use of Princess Nausicaa and Odysseus swapping positions and angles, along with sailors' hands resembling feet, a bow working in reverse, and a Cyclops with three eyes, raises concerns about the authenticity of the work. The AI-generated film has received mixed reactions on social media, with some critics comparing it to "eating a bowl of wet cardboard" or calling it "outstandingly bad."
Written by urgent.news from TechRadar's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
