O'Callaghan rebuffs request for mediator in legal aid row

Minister for Justice Jim O Callaghan has refused a Law Society request for a mediator to help resolve the dispute surrounding the new criminal legal aid scheme. The minister claims mediation is not appropriate, as the High Court is expected to rule on the matter next month. The issue, stemming from the flat-fee payment scheme for criminal defense solicitors, has led to nationwide court hearing disruptions, causing many defense solicitors to withdraw their services.

In a letter to the Law Society, O Callaghan stated that he believes mediation would not assist in resolving the current issues. The High Court's decision on the matter is set for October 13th, 2026. O Callaghan also disputes that there has been a drop in criminal legal aid certificates issued since the scheme's inception. He notes that over 600 solicitors remain on the criminal legal aid panel, with 39 court areas having assigned certificates.

Furthermore, there has been a rise in participation, with three new solicitors joining and 24 solicitors reinstated. The minister claims initial evidence indicates the scheme is achieving its goal of reducing court appearances, as over 25% of cases have been resolved and more than 75% concluded within a single court appearance.