The Shards sputters to an insulting close
A befuddling non-ending piles on the ambiguity… and not in an interesting way.
The Shards, a serial-killer story by Bret Easton Ellis, concludes with a disappointing lack of resolution. The adaptation by Ryan Murphy, however, aims to maintain the ambiguity present in the source material. Throughout the series finale, several plot threads remain unresolved, leaving viewers questioning the identities of the Trawler, who attacked Terry, who killed Debbie's horse, and who attacked Susan.
The show does not provide answers to these questions, which feels perplexing given the central nature of these plot points. While some viewers might have preferred the book's claustrophobic atmosphere, this adaptation opts for a more straightforward approach, which raises more questions than it answers. The love triangle, a central element of the story, remains unresolved as well.
Susan's decision to leave Thom for Robert, a storyline that seemed inevitable, is treated with little depth or nuance. Robert's character becomes increasingly unpleasant as he continues to humiliate Thom and assert his dominance, while Susan's reaction to this situation is underwhelming. The finale also focuses on other subplots, such as the attack on Susan's home and Debbie's discovery of a tape recording her father and boyfriend having sex.
These events, while interesting, are not fully explored, leaving the audience with unanswered questions. Overall, The Shards' ending leaves much to be desired, as it fails to provide the clarity and closure that its complex narrative warrants.
Written by urgent.news from The A.V. Club's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
