Why hair clay beats gel for natural-looking hold

Hair gel and clay serve the same purpose of keeping hairstyles in place, but they achieve this through distinct mechanisms. A study in the International Journal of Cosmetic Science explores the properties of styling polymers, including hold, flexibility, tack, and combing, while another Journal of Cosmetic Science investigation examines how polymer films impact the stiffness of styled hair.

This knowledge explains a common observation: many gels create a defined film as they dry, while clay-based products aim to retain hair's pliability and texture. If the goal is to appear styled without looking overly set, clay has a distinct advantage. An overview of hair clay and its users Hair clay is a styling product composed of mineral clay, typically kaolin or bentonite, along with waxes, oils, or other styling ingredients.

For instance, American Crew's Matte Clay combines kaolin, beeswax, and carnauba wax. This dense product adds separation and control without the typically wet finish associated with traditional gel. Pomade serves a different aesthetic purpose. It is generally more suitable for neat side parts, slick backs, and other combed styles where some shine is desired.

Gel is preferable when a firm, fixed result takes precedence over the ability to restyle the hair. In the UAE, where hair texture and environmental conditions vary, clay's flexibility proves practical for transitioning between warm outdoor conditions and air-conditioned interiors. A workable style can be easily reshaped with fingers rather than needing to be recreated entirely.

Choosing the right product The ideal product depends on two factors: hold and finish. A strong hold does not necessarily result in a glossy or rigid appearance. Some clays provide significant control with minimal shine, while pomades can offer medium hold with a smoother finish. Hair density also plays a role. Fine hair may be overpowered by too much dense product, so starting with a small amount is advisable.

In contrast, thick hair may require more grip and distribution. Key questions to consider are how firmly the product holds, how shiny the finish is, and whether it remains manageable with fingers or a comb. Product recommendations Based on these considerations, American Crew's Matte Clay is recommended as the primary choice for those seeking to move away from the rigid appearance of gel.

Its formula, which includes kaolin and beeswax, provides high hold, workable control, and added texture. The product is applied to dry or towel-dried hair and shaped with fingers for separation rather than combing it flat. This clay is particularly effective for short, textured styles where shine is not the primary goal. BASED Bodyworks Sea Salt Spray Clay serves as an effective pre-styler that works best when it does not need to create all the shape itself.

This 250ml sea salt spray, priced at 250ml, offers light hold, texture, and volume enhancement before applying the finishing product. The formula includes sea salt, kelp extract, aloe vera, and vitamin B5. Applying it to damp hair, shaping the hair while drying, and then using clay sparingly at the end is recommended. This approach is especially beneficial for finer or flatter hair, as the clay concentrates on definition rather than being applied heavily for volume.

BASED Bodyworks Pomade is also recommended as an alternative to clay. It provides medium, flexible hold with natural shine, thanks to ingredients like bentonite, beeswax, castor oil, shea butter, and jojoba oil. This pomade is chosen when a cleaner, more polished look is desired, with cleaner lines and a side part or slicker flow.

Unlike clay, this pomade allows for easier reworking, making it a less rigid option for achieving a neat finish compared to a hard-setting gel. A finishing touch The Beardo Compact Sheesham Comb complements these products by changing the character of the styling product. This pocket-sized comb, made of Sheesham wood, is designed for detailed grooming and styling, making it ideal for establishing direction without resulting in an overly neat finish.

It is particularly useful when using pomade for a defined side part or controlled shape, and it is also helpful for midday adjustments without needing to carry another styling product. Conclusion While clay does not universally outperform gel, it offers a compelling alternative for everyday hair that should retain texture and movement.

American Crew's Matte Clay is the strongest starting point due to its kaolin and wax formula, which is explicitly designed for workable hold and texture. Pairing it with BASED Bodyworks Sea Salt Spray creates a pre-styling foundation, reducing the need for heavy finishing product.