Mother feared 'failing' baby after months of inconsistent advice postpartum
First-time mother Maddy Barrett was worried she was "starving" her baby when she could not get her newborn to latch properly. She endured months of different advice from multiple practitioners, which left her feeling scared.
Maddy Barrett yearned for empowerment to make informed decisions after welcoming her firstborn. However, conflicting advice from various healthcare professionals left her terrified that she was doing something wrong. Upon giving birth, nurses, lactation consultants, and midwives offered inconsistent guidance on breastfeeding. Despite the overwhelming advice, she left the hospital without a feeding plan or ongoing support.
As her daughter's weight dropped due to insufficient milk supply, Barrett was put on a triple feeding plan, consisting of breastfeeding, pumping, and formula. Exhausted and sleep-deprived, she felt her life revolved around feeding her daughter. Similar experiences were reported by other women facing inconsistent advice postpartum.
A 2024 review of Australian antenatal care guidelines revealed low scores in clarity, applicability, and editorial independence. Dr. Nicole Highet, executive director of the Centre of Perinatal Excellence, emphasized that conflicting advice can increase distress and worsen mental health. Guidelines may be outdated due to infrequent reviews, and they may not always align with policy.
Dr. Erin Seeto, director of clinical services at the Gidget Foundation, noted that postnatal depression and anxiety can affect one in five women and one in 10 men. Lack of continuity in care can lead to missed diagnoses, fueling calls for consistency among practitioners. The impact of conflicting advice on new mothers was profound for Barrett, who eventually discovered her daughter had a severe tongue-tie affecting her latch.
She stressed the need for consistent, evidence-based, and compassionate support, as well as a feeling of being heard.
Written by urgent.news from ABC News AU's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
