In Iceland, the mystery of the poet, the tomb and the Danish grocer

In a grassy field surrounded by lava stones, a modest tombstone marks the resting place of an Icelandic legend: Jonas Hallgrimsson. However, there is uncertainty as to whether the bones beneath it truly belong to the famed poet or a Danish grocer. Hallgrimsson, who died in 1845, is remembered for his contributions as a poet, naturalist, and founder of Icelandic national romanticism.

Despite his enduring popularity, the question of who lies beneath the stone has lingered due to the historic uncertainty surrounding his burial.

Standing near the somber, lichen-covered tombstone, geneticist and eccentric Kari Stefansson, 77, is a devoted admirer of Hallgrimsson. He can recite the poet's verses from memory, expressing his deep emotional connection to the renowned figure. However, the mystery of the tomb has left many enthusiasts hesitant. They are calling for the grave to be opened, seeking confirmation that the remains are indeed those of the beloved poet. A formal request has been submitted to authorities.

The story of Hallgrimsson's remains began in Denmark, where he passed away after falling down a staircase. His bones were initially placed in a grave alongside those of three to five other individuals. In 1946, amid Iceland's newfound independence from Denmark, the remains were repatriated to the North Atlantic island as a symbol of the nation's pride. However, a century underground has taken a toll on the remains, which are in poor condition, with no skull or legs present.

While the debate continues, the remains rest in a small church near Thingvellir, a UNESCO World Heritage site and the original location of the Althing, the world's oldest functioning parliament. The grave is surprisingly unassuming, and its location serves as a landing pad for VIP helicopter visits. Curiously, a family even picnicked on the slab, unaware of its significance.

Some argue that the tale of mixed-up bones is a "nasty rumour," citing a 1946 photograph as evidence. However, others, like biologist Kari Stefansson, believe that the debate should continue, emphasizing the importance of preserving the mystery. Stefansson suggests that if the remains are indeed Hallgrimsson's, Icelanders should apologize for disturbing his peaceful rest and then cover the grave once more.