‘Elsinore’ Review: Andrew Scott’s Towering Performance as a Dying Actor Can’t Overcome AIDS-Movie Awards Bait Clichés

Telluride - A film that delves into the real-life production of Shakespeare's "Hamlet" takes the stage at the Telluride Film Festival. The emotional climax, driven by music, unfolds during a significant performance of the time-honored tragedy, resonating with the characters' lives. The audience weeps as they bear witness to a shattering rendition of the line "remember me."

This scene at the Telluride Film Festival, which marked the world premiere of Chloé Zhao's "Hamnet," was replicated for Simon Stone's "Elsinore" this year. The latter film stands as a testament to Shakespeare's enduring influence and the power of "Hamlet." While "Elsinore" may have a more limited release than Zhao's critically acclaimed "Hamnet," boasting eight Oscar nominations and profits exceeding $100 million, it remains emotionally impactful and features Andrew Scott's most compelling performance.

Set in 1989, the story unfolds during the National Theater's production of "Hamlet," starring Daniel Day-Lewis, who is in the early stages of his career. Day-Lewis experiences a breakdown amidst a performance and departs the stage, never to return. The film transitions back to the preceding month, when Ian Charleson, renowned for his role in "Chariots of Fire," attempts to maintain his acting career amidst personal struggles.

Struggling with his sexuality and living with AIDS during a period when the disease was rampant within the gay community, Charleson's life takes a dark turn. He confides in friends about his condition, expressing his anxiety about aging and how he feels "wasting time." Charismatic and talented, Charleson auditions for the National Theater's "Hamlet" role in the wake of Day-Lewis' departure.

Director Richard Eyre (portrayed by Johnny Flynn) offers him the role, despite his doubts about Charleson's suitability due to his perceived lack of "poshness." However, Charleson's dedication and determination lead him to take on the enormous physical and emotional demands of the role, even as his health deteriorates. As the film unflinchingly depicts the mortality themes present in "Hamlet," Charleson's portrayal of Hamlet is both casual and captivating.

The music score, crafted by Stefan Gregory, complements the scenes with depth and momentum, often utilizing solo piano. The film's title, "Elsinore," not only references the Danish castle where Prince Hamlet resides but also symbolizes the imposing National Theater building in London. Andrew Scott delivers a performance that intertwines humor, anguish, and vulnerability, making "Elsinore" a film that touches the heart without ever becoming overly pompous.

Scott's portrayal of Hamlet is equal parts amusing and tortured, skillfully navigating the complex emotions of a man nearing the end of his life. While Charleson's journey culminates in his triumphant return to the stage at the National Theater, "Elsinore" ultimately leaves the audience with a sense of both melancholy and inspiration.