‘Worst QB Decision in the History of the NFL’ — Radio Host Calls for Vikings To ‘Move On From’ J.J. McCarthy

On January 4, 2026, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, radio host Jason Smith of Fox Sports sounded off on the Minnesota Vikings' quarterback situation. Smith lamented that there was no way J.J. McCarthy could be part of the Vikings for Week 1. He went on to call the team's decision to keep McCarthy as the starting quarterback the "worst QB decision in the history of the NFL."

Meanwhile, Vikings general manager Nolan Teasley dismissed Smith's harsh words. Teasley stated that McCarthy's role is to continue to develop, improve, and support his teammates. He also highlighted McCarthy's potential, talent, and impressive athletic abilities. Teasley further pointed out that McCarthy was drafted in the first round for a reason and expressed anticipation for his continued development in the system.

Despite McCarthy's struggles in his last 10 starts, during which he threw 12 interceptions and only 11 touchdowns, Teasley remained optimistic about the young quarterback's future. He emphasized that McCarthy has the hardest job in sports, having only started 10 games so far, and his story is far from over. Teasley also mentioned that the Vikings are unlikely to exercise McCarthy's fifth-year option.

With McCarthy expected to be demoted to third-string quarterback, the Vikings may consider trade offers. However, it seems unlikely that they would simply move on from the quarterback, as Smith suggested.