New research shows a neutrino laser is impossible
Due to physical and fundamental limitations, an earlier proposal for producing laserlike beams of neutrinos cannot be achieved, scientists report.
New research has revealed that a neutrino laser, a concept once proposed by scientists, is physically and fundamentally impossible. In two companion papers published in Physical Review Letters, MIT physicists Wolfgang Ketterle, along with postdocs Hanzhen Lin and Yu-Kun Lu, have demonstrated the flaws in the proposed neutrino laser concept and a similar one for gamma-rays.
The idea behind the neutrino laser was based on the phenomenon of "superradiance," which has been observed for photons. Superradiance occurs when a cloud of atoms, cooled to near absolute zero, forms a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC). Atoms in a BEC move in sync, scattering particles like photons back out in the same direction, amplifying the effect exponentially and creating a laser-like beam.
Researchers proposed that a similar superradiant effect could be achieved with radioactive atoms, which naturally emit neutrinos as they decay.
Ketterle, a leading expert on Bose-Einstein condensates, expressed skepticism about the proposal. He explained that due to the high energy of neutrinos (a million times more than photons), the atoms would recoil at extremely high speeds, far beyond the capacity of a Bose-Einstein condensate. This recoil would disrupt the synchronized movement of atoms within the condensate, rendering the neutrino laser concept unfeasible.
MIT physicist Joe Formaggio, who initially proposed the neutrino laser concept alongside Ben Jones, acknowledged the new findings as a constructive challenge to their original idea. He emphasized the importance of peer review in the scientific process, noting that the community's scrutiny could lead to a better understanding of the phenomenon.
Written by urgent.news from MIT News Research's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
