I've watched all of The Paper season 2 and still think it's trying too hard to be Parks and Recreation — but the Brits are the best part of The Office spinoff

The Paper season 2 premiered on Peacock on September 9th, but viewers have found themselves divided over the show's second season. Despite its potential, the series struggles to reach its full potential, still grappling with the same issues that plagued its first season. Editor-in-Chief Ned (Domhnall Gleeson) continues to search for compelling stories for his team, while Esmeralda (Sabrina Impacciatore) remains self-focused and Nicole (Ramona Young) becomes increasingly similar to Kelly Kapoor.

While there are moments of humor and laughter, the show frequently feels like it's trying too hard to emulate Parks and Recreation, with the most notable difference being the genuine camaraderie present in the latter. The Paper's authenticity lacks in its community-driven narrative, making it difficult for viewers to fully engage with the series. The season's 10 episodes struggle to maintain coherence, with some episodes feeling like stagnant filler content.

One standout performance comes from Tim Key, who plays Ken and complements Esmeralda's chaotic personality with his sharp wit. Key's partnership with Gbemisola Ikumelo, who portrays Nicole's accountant sister, creates a compelling double act that shines throughout the season. Ikumelo's transformation from a character known for her comedic timing on Last One Laughing UK season 2 to a more complex and nuanced role is impressive.

However, her performance would benefit from more opportunities on UK comedy shows. While the series is not without its flaws, The Paper season 2 is not the worst TV show or comedy series of 2026.