Is Kyle Shanahan’s most infamous draft tradition finally about to bear fruit?

The San Francisco 49ers have a history of spending high draft picks on running backs, only to see them struggle for playing time and ultimately move on. However, entering the 2026 season, there is reason for optimism that this pattern might finally change. In the four years since the Shanahan-Lynch regime began, the 49ers have invested six draft picks in running backs, with most of those selections producing limited success.

This year, the team drafted Kaelon Black in the third round and James in the fifth round, offering hope that these picks could provide the necessary support for star running back Christian McCaffrey. Both Black and James have demonstrated skills that could help alleviate the pressure on McCaffrey, who has dealt with injuries throughout his time with the team.

Black showcased good pass protection skills during preseason, while James showed burst and contact balance in preseason action. While James only saw action in one preseason game due to injury, his performance has given reason for optimism about his potential to contribute to the 49ers' offense. The 49ers are not expecting Black or James to replicate McCaffrey's impact, but the flashes of promise from both players suggest they may be able to help carry the load when McCaffrey is unable to play.

The hope is that this season could mark the end of the long wait for Shanahan's commitment to drafting running backs to pay off.