Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Culture

A dance-off brings The Shards’ failures as both a slasher and a teen drama to light

The episode, more interested in gimmicks and jokes, wastes a good Debbie spotlight.

A dance-off brings The Shards’ failures as both a slasher and a teen drama to light

The Shards, the latest addition to Ryan Murphy's series of flawed offerings, has fallen into a disarray that defies any expectation of a coherent narrative. The episode "Murder On The Dancefloor" attempts to capitalize on the central competition, Dance Off!, yet fails to deliver on its potential. The setting of the dance-off provides an opportunity for engaging slasher moments, but instead, the episode devolves into a chaotic mishmash of questionable dialogue and poorly constructed subplots.

Debbie, the supporting character given the chance to shine, is the episode's only saving grace. Her personal conflict with Susan, who triumphs in the competition, brings a shred of emotional depth to the episode. However, even her story is overshadowed by the show's penchant for indulging in random and unnecessary tangents. The supporting cast, including the production team characters who spend their time partaking in drug use and bickering, and Cha Cha, who is inexplicably woven into a convoluted subplot, only serve to further undermine the episode's credibility.

The love triangle storyline continues to drag, with Thom and Robert's contentious relationship remaining the same as in the previous episode. While the interaction between Thom and Robert is entertaining, it fails to offer any meaningful progress or resolution. The scenes with Dance Off! host Tony Cruz and Debbie's nemesis Cha Cha are particularly perplexing, lacking any semblance of believability or emotional resonance.

Rhonda's appearance at the taping, after Cha Cha's disappearance is reported, offers a brief moment of intrigue; however, the episode ultimately falters in delivering any genuine emotion or investment in the characters. Murphy's frequent reliance on dark comedy and stylization, rather than genuine character investment, leaves the audience disengaged and underwhelmed.

As the series progresses, it becomes increasingly clear that The Shards' central theme—its characters—fails to resonate with the audience, leaving a disappointing void in the wake of its abrupt conclusion.

Written by urgent.news from The A.V. Club's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at avclub.com →

More in Culture

More from Thursday 20 August →