Fantasy Football: Caleb Williams vs. Justin Herbert and more QB debates you may have to face in your 2026 drafts

In the world of fantasy football, quarterback selection can be a daunting task. However, the 2026 NFL season seems to offer more clarity in this department. Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the upcoming season, and then consider these four quarterback debates.

First up is Drake Maye vs. Joe Burrow. Burrow's consistency over the years, boasting impressive stats like 8.9 YPA and leading the NFL in various categories, make him a strong contender. However, his injury history and lack of running ability make him less appealing to some. Drake Maye, on the other hand, excelled in his second year with a high YPA, QB rating, and impressive rushing stats. With a perfect fit in A.J. Brown, Maye could be the better pick in this matchup.

Next is Caleb Williams vs. Justin Herbert. Both offenses show promise, with the Chargers' offensive coordinator Ben Johnson bringing similar results to the Los Angeles Chargers as he did in Chicago. Williams' young targets and potential improvement under Johnson's system give him an edge over the older, more injury-prone Herbert.

Matthew Stafford vs. Jared Goff are also great options. Both have proven themselves in the pocket, but the addition of new offensive coordinators could make a difference. Stafford's defense might be a concern, while the Rams' new defense could be a top-five unit. Considering these factors, Goff edges out Stafford in this debate.

Lastly, Patrick Mahomes vs. Bo Nix in the AFC West. Both quarterbacks have had impressive seasons, but the Chiefs and Broncos face different challenges. Mahomes' injury history and diminished completion rates may hinder his performance, while Nix's solid rehab and a strong WR corps make him a tempting choice. However, the addition of Kenneth Walker III to the Chiefs' offense could shift the dynamic in their favor, making Goff the slightly better pick.