H-1B lottery rejected him 3 times: How an Indian professional got O-1 visa

An Indian data analytics professional named Sohan Sethi faced three consecutive rejections in the US H-1B visa lottery. Frustrated with this uncertainty, Sethi decided to pursue an O-1 visa, a category for individuals who can demonstrate extraordinary ability in their field.

Sethi, who grew up in Mumbai, had completed his undergraduate degree in computer engineering at the University of Mumbai and later earned a master's degree in the United States. After graduating in 2023, he joined a healthcare company in a senior business analyst role and later became a manager of analytics and reporting. However, his H-1B status remained in limbo as he was not selected in three consecutive H-1B lotteries.

In April 2025, after his second rejection, Sethi began preparing his O-1 visa application. The O-1 is a temporary work visa for those who can prove extraordinary ability in areas such as science, education, business, or athletics. Unlike the H-1B lottery, the O-1 does not rely on a cap, but it does require substantial evidence of sustained national or international acclaim.

Sethi and his immigration lawyer compiled over 700 pages of supporting material, including media coverage, industry judging roles, awards, published work, and recommendation letters. This intense effort cost him approximately $13,000 in legal fees. His third H-1B non-selection came in March 2026, leaving him with only about 100 days before his STEM OPT work authorization was set to expire on July 5, 2026.

During this tense period, Sethi considered various alternatives, such as returning to India, pursuing another master's degree, or relocating to Canada or the UK. However, he ultimately decided that the US offered the best opportunities for his career in data analytics and AI.

When the O-1 visa was finally approved in March 2026, Sethi received the news while at his desk in Chicago. Overwhelmed with relief, he immediately called his mother and brother in India. With his visa secured, Sethi now manages a team of analysts in healthcare data and analytics. He has also shared his experience and advice on LinkedIn, offering guidance to others navigating the complex US immigration landscape.