Who (or What) Generates Images for EFF?
We’ve had a few questions from EFF supporters lately, asking whether the images we use on our blog posts, or on donation and shop items, have been created with AI image generators. We’d like to answer these questions and clarify our internal policy regarding image creation. EFF images are all made by human beings, not by automated image generators, with very rare exceptions. This is an internal…
Recent inquiries from EFF supporters have prompted the organization to address questions about the origins of images used in their blog posts and merchandise. EFF is transparent about the fact that all their images are created by human designers, not AI generators, with very few exceptions. This internal decision is rooted in several key considerations.
Firstly, EFF's designers possess specialized knowledge and expertise, honed through years of collaboration with the organization's legal team, technologists, and activists. By employing human designers, EFF believes their images communicate a sense of authenticity and clarity that AI-generated images may lack. Moreover, the team feels that human-created images better embody the values they uphold - honesty and trustworthiness.
Aesthetic preferences also play a role in their decision. EFF designers appreciate the creative process and visual outcomes produced by hand, which allows for greater control over image variations tailored to different posts. While there may be occasional delays compared to AI-generated images, the team believes the results are more satisfactory and enduring.
Another crucial aspect is copyright protection. AI-generated images could potentially infringe on existing copyrights, creating potential legal disputes for EFF. By generating their own images, they mitigate the risk of copyright infringement allegations, enabling them to promote digital rights, including the right to fair use, without fear of litigation.
There are rare instances where an EFF designer might utilize an AI-generated image as a small component within a larger illustration. In such cases, the organization will provide additional clarification specifying the elements used and the AI tool employed.
To maintain transparency, EFF will now credit all their image creations with "Image created by EFF" in the lower right-hand corner of each banner. This policy acknowledges EFF's nuanced stance on the evolving landscape of image generation technology while remaining true to their brand and values.
Despite the advancements in AI, EFF continues to advocate for the rights of technologists and uphold the public's legal and legitimate use of these tools. They are determined to maintain the integrity of their brand and the authenticity of their communications. All images created by EFF are licensed under Creative Commons Attribution, allowing users to freely use, share, and remix their work, provided they attribute the source to EFF.
For high-resolution versions, users can access images on EFF's Flickr page or directly contact the organization with their requests. Furthermore, supporters can enjoy the artwork generated by EFF as a thank-you gift when making donations to the organization.
Written by urgent.news from EFF Deeplinks's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
