Suspensions more 'painful' than fines: Drivers, experts on stricter demerit rules

A stricter demerit points system is set to tighten Singapore's traffic rules, with a lower threshold for the first suspension and longer suspensions. The changes, effective from January 1, 2027, aim to deter unsafe driving and keep dangerous motorists off the roads. Drivers and experts, however, have mixed views on the effectiveness of suspensions.

For some, like Martin, a first-time offender who ran two red lights, a suspension and subsequent retraining course successfully curbed risky behavior. However, others, including a driver with a five-year suspension, argue that fines are insufficient deterrents, and suspensions are more painful as they threaten one's driving entitlement. They point out that the financial hit from a year off the road can cost between S$10,000 and S$13,000 in Certificate of Entitlement value alone.

Experts suggest that suspensions may not deter reckless drivers who prioritize evading enforcement. Sociologist Tan Ern Ser notes that suspensions send a message that there is 'no room for complacency' and could challenge individuals' optimism bias. However, he suggests public shaming or incentive systems for safe drivers as more effective deterrents.