4 overreactions from the Panthers-Cardinals Hall of Fame banger
The first game of NFL preseason had no right to be that good. The Panthers and Cardinals gave us a Hall of Fame classic on Thursday night that came down to the final play, with rookie quarterback Haynes King rushing for a touchdown as time expired to give Carolina the win. Not only was the […]
1. Haynes King's rise in Carolina's quarterback hierarchy is not imminent. Although he had an impressive performance and scored three touchdowns, he is ranked third behind Bryce Young and Kenny Pickett. His success may bolster his chances for the backup role, but supplanting the starter is an overreaction.
2. Carson Beck's performance should not be overhyped as a potential superstar. While he exhibited strong arm velocity and touch, the Panthers' defense was subpar, particularly on the secondary. More attention is needed to see if Beck can maintain this level against actual defenses before any draft speculation.
3. The discussion surrounding the Panthers' pass defense is premature. While Beck's performance was impacted by defensive issues, this does not mean the pass defense is in trouble. The limited situational playcalling from the coaching staff also played a role in the poor showing, making it too early to panic.
4. The praise for Carson Beck and Ja'Seem Reed as potential top receivers is excessive. Both players had strong performances, but their backgrounds as undrafted free agents and lesser-known prospects should temper expectations. Reaching the 53-man roster would be a significant achievement for both, but labeling them as top-four rotation receivers is an overstatement.
Written by urgent.news from SB Nation's reporting — not their text. Machine-written; read the original for the full account.
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
