{
  "id": 21150528,
  "title": "Tavleen Singh writes: Is Prime Minister Modi scared of Rahul Gandhi?",
  "url": "https://urgent.news/2026/11/22/tavleen-singh-writes-is-prime-minister-modi-scared-of-rahul-gandhi",
  "topic": "world",
  "section": "World",
  "published": "2026-11-22T01:20:00.000Z",
  "source": {
    "name": "The Indian Express",
    "slug": "the-indian-express",
    "url": "https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/tavleen-singh-writes-is-prime-minister-modi-scared-of-rahul-gandhi-10973166/"
  },
  "original_language": "en",
  "account": "For nearly half a century, political columns have become accustomed to being treated as a sort of seer with uncanny abilities to perceive things that others cannot. Frequently, strangers at airports and restaurants ask questions such as whether the popularity of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has waned or if he will secure a fourth term as prime minister. Recently, inquiries have mostly centered around the future of the ruling dynasty and its prospective leader, Rahul Gandhi. Questions have been posed about whether Rahul has evolved into a genuine leader capable of upholding his family's legacy and assuming the prime minister's role. With three prime ministers originating from the Gandhi family, it is inevitable to consider whether Rahul will continue the family tradition or become the next prime minister himself. His grandmother, Sonia Gandhi, was effectively prime minister for a decade, further fueling speculation.\n\nIn response to such questions, I often pose inquiries of my own, such as whether the voters who previously supported Modi in the previous general elections have reconsidered their stance. Many of my questioners voted for Modi in the past three elections but express reluctance to do so in the future due to growing disillusionment and concerns about rising corruption. However, when asked if they would support the Gandhi dynasty again, they hesitate. They are uncertain if they would prefer Rahul Gandhi as the prime minister.\n\nDuring a recent visit to the United States, Rahul declared that India is experiencing an \"economic disaster.\" Typically, he focuses on convincing the Indian diaspora that \"Indian democracy is dead\" during his overseas travels. This time, he highlighted unemployment, the lack of manufacturing progress, distress in the farm sector, and the unhappiness of small and medium businesses. When discussing the destruction of the \"economic architecture built by Congress over decades,\" Rahul's remarks left me perplexed. From personal experience, I recall the inferior goods \"made in India\" and how people who could afford it sought out foreign products or smuggled them in. Change only began when India was led by a prime minister who did not belong to the Gandhi family and dismantled the license raj that stifled the economy while neighboring countries in Southeast Asia flourished, and China emerged as the economic superpower it is today. It is commendable that Modi has avoided introducing the BJP's version of Nehruvian socialism, often referred to as \"Gandhian socialism\" to mask the fact that it is the same old idea.\n\nIs Rahul Gandhi a Nehruvian socialist or a socialist of any kind? Would he revert to the economic ideologies espoused by his grandmother? Sonia Gandhi, in her memoir, credits her husband with \"liberalising\" the Indian economy; however, this is not an accurate depiction. Consulting Bangalore's \"tech-bros,\" they reveal that importing a computer into India took over a year and numerous trips to Delhi. The dismantling of the license raj began under P V Narasimha Rao, who demonstrated the courage to abandon Nehruvian socialism despite referring to himself as a socialist until his last breath. Regrettably, Modi has failed to continue the reforms initiated by Rao's transformation, rendering doing business in India a daunting task, except for a select few tycoons at the top.\n\nDuring a recent gathering of businessmen, the prime minister criticized them for not paying their workers better and for not investing more. Instead, he needs to introspect on why private investment has not been stimulated. Rahul Gandhi seems to believe that the sluggish progress is attributed to the Congress party no longer being in power, a notion he must reassess promptly. Returning to the question I am frequently asked: is Rahul Gandhi being taken more seriously? Is he the only formidable challenger to Modi? Recent hysteria within the BJP ranks regarding his overseas appearances suggests this may be the case. Upon uttering anything in foreign lands, he has been denounced by BJP spokespersons as anti-India, with some deliberately distorting his name and mocking him about his mother's Italian origins. Whether I believe he has reinvented himself as a mature and gravitas-filled leader is irrelevant; what matters is that the BJP perceives him as such. Meanwhile, Rahul Gandhi must do more to rebuild the fractured foundation of the party he inherited as a family inheritance if he aspires to be the primary opposition contender in the next general election. Additionally, he needs to appoint a shadow cabinet that would offer a glimpse into the kind of politician he truly is – one who values courtiers or one who embraces strong ministers.",
  "summary": null,
  "key_points": [],
  "editors_take": null,
  "illustration": null,
  "coverage": {
    "outlets": 1,
    "also_reported_by": []
  },
  "ai_generated": true,
  "disclaimer": "Summaries, key points and the editor’s take are written by software from other outlets’ reporting and may contain errors — always check the linked original."
}