{
  "id": 20594638,
  "title": "Was Achilles Conscious?",
  "url": "https://urgent.news/2026/11/18/was-achilles-conscious",
  "topic": "finance",
  "section": "Finance & Markets",
  "published": "2026-11-18T12:18:00.000Z",
  "source": {
    "name": "Marginal Revolution",
    "slug": "marginal-revolution",
    "url": "https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/11/was-achilles-conscious.html"
  },
  "original_language": "en",
  "account": "The modern interpretation of Homer’s Greeks suggests they lacked inner life, according to a recent introduction to Julian Jaynes's bicameral theory of mind. Jaynes posited that intelligent behavior came before introspective consciousness in his book The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind. He posited that people could accomplish tasks and navigate society without mentally representing themselves as an \"I\" within an internal world. Jaynes theorized that routine behavior was habit-based, but complex situations triggered \"command hallucinations,\" voices perceived as gods, ancestors, or rulers issuing commands. These two parts of the mind—one issuing commands and the other obeying—formed the \"bicameral\" mind. Around 1200 BC, during the time between the Iliad and the Odyssey, humans began to imagine alternatives and narrate their actions internally, essentially becoming conscious. This transition was not an inherent biological trait but a result of cultural and linguistic evolution. Initially skeptical of Jaynes's theory, the idea of unconsciously normal human beings seemed implausible. Now, however, the possibility of a civilization of thinking, talking, and performing beings, yet unconscious, begins to make more sense. AIs serve as an existence proof for this concept. While linguistic differences between the Iliad and later texts are insufficient evidence for such a significant claim, they can be explained through other means. The evidence for a near-universal transition in a few centuries remains tenuous, leading the author to favor continuity based on Occam's razor. Additionally, the presence of conscious-like behavior in some animals and the potential for AIs to describe their actions in conscious terms challenge Jaynes's theory. The author questions whether this means past humans couldn't suffer or deserve moral consideration, emphasizing that it raises the question of what kind of consciousness we are seeking in AIs. Ultimately, the debate surrounding Jaynes's theory highlights the difficulty in determining consciousness across different entities, whether past humans, other animals, or machines.",
  "summary": "Homer’s Greeks had no inner life. That’s the title of a recent introduction to Julian Jaynes’s bicameral theory of mind. To recap: in The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, Jaynes argued that intelligent behavior preceded introspective consciousness. People could speak, learn, farm, build cities, and solve problems without mentally representing […] The post Was…",
  "key_points": [],
  "editors_take": null,
  "illustration": null,
  "coverage": {
    "outlets": 1,
    "also_reported_by": []
  },
  "ai_generated": true,
  "disclaimer": "Summaries, key points and the editor’s take are written by software from other outlets’ reporting and may contain errors — always check the linked original."
}