{
  "id": 20305948,
  "title": "‘BMA is not a refugee reception office,’ high court told in asylum seekers case",
  "url": "https://urgent.news/2026/11/16/bma-is-not-a-refugee-reception-office-high-court-told-in-asylum",
  "topic": "world",
  "section": "World",
  "published": "2026-11-16T17:10:08.000Z",
  "source": {
    "name": "The Citizen",
    "slug": "the-citizen",
    "url": "https://www.citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/courts/bma-not-refugee-reception-office-high-court-asylum-seekers-case/"
  },
  "original_language": "en",
  "account": "The Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg is holding a three-day hearing to determine if undocumented migrants seeking asylum can remain in detention. This hearing follows conflicting rulings by single judges on how to apply the Constitutional Court’s Scalabrini judgment, which previously prevented the state from deporting potential asylum seekers before their claims were assessed. Some judges have ordered immediate releases, while others have allowed detention to continue.\n\nAdvocate NF Chauke, representing migrants arrested after entering outside ports of entry, argued that his clients, convicted under Section 49(1) of the Immigration Act and having served their sentences, should be released once they express an intention to apply for asylum. He rejected the notion that released individuals would not register with Home Affairs. Chauke emphasized that courts should step in to prevent unlawful detention, stating that the courts have a duty to stand between detained individuals and Home Affairs.\n\nAdvocate Anton Katz, representing two clients who had been released but not yet received asylum seeker visas, contended that it was absurd for someone who could not be deported to still be detained. Katz argued that the courts have a duty to stand between unlawfully detained individuals and Home Affairs, asserting that the decision to detain or release must be black and white.\n\nHome Affairs attorney Johann Hershensohn proposed a period of about 14 days for detention, subject to case-by-case assessment. He maintained that the Scalabrini Center only removed the good cause requirement and did not overturn the earlier Constitutional Court ruling. Hershensohn rejected the idea that the power to detain had ended, describing the principle that bars deportation of asylum seekers as a shield rather than a sword. He highlighted the existing process outlined by the Lawyers for Human Rights, which requires an official to consider release first, followed by a magistrate hearing the person within 48 hours, with a court then authorizing detention for up to 30 days and later for up to 90 days.\n\nThe judges pressed the lawyers for evidence and addresses, questioning whether the clients had expressed their intention for asylum at the time of entry. Judge Elmarie van der Schyff pointed out that the clients entered outside a port of entry and did not raise asylum before the magistrate. Chauke maintained that the continued detention of his clients was unlawful. The court also addressed the capacity issues faced by the department, with Hershensohn acknowledging that five offices handle approximately 108 matters a day, each processing between 18 and 22 cases.",
  "summary": "A lawyer representing asylum seekers argued that it was absurd that a person who could not be deported for now could still be detained.",
  "key_points": [],
  "editors_take": null,
  "illustration": null,
  "coverage": {
    "outlets": 1,
    "also_reported_by": []
  },
  "ai_generated": true,
  "disclaimer": "Summaries, key points and the editor’s take are written by software from other outlets’ reporting and may contain errors — always check the linked original."
}